“We didn’t get a chance to hold a life jacket” – survivor tells COI
November 19 2026
Testimony from White Water, Region One residents Grenville Smith and his wife, Rosel Smith, as the Commission of Inquiry into the capsizing and subsequent sinking of the MV Barima continued at the Arthur Chung Conference Center, surfaced several major operational, mechanical, and post-tragedy failures after the couple survived the sinking while losing their thirteen-year-old daughter, Shamira Smith, and seven-year-old grandson, Arif Daniels.
Engine trouble, overloading and rapid sinking
The mechanical and operational issues from Grenville Smith’s testimony that the MV Barima vessel appeared overloaded, suffered a noticeable drop in engine power roughly an hour before going down, and rolled over twice in less than ten seconds after word spread that water had entered downstairs.
“The boat was overload and it went on one engine,” Grenville testified, explaining that around nine o’clock he heard the engine sound change and “boil down” rather than cut off completely as the vessel lost control in heavy swells, after conditions had earlier felt normal between half past four and half past five in the afternoon.
Grenville recalled that roughly one hundred and eighty passengers were aboard across the upper and lower decks, alongside cargo including boxes, sideways loads near their seating area, and bags of onions stacked along the sides and in a separate back room near the engine area, while cooking gas bottles were also seen floating in the ocean afterward. After someone reported plenty of water downstairs, the vessel tilted within two to three minutes and rolled a second time in less than ten seconds without ever righting itself.
“It kant and it never balanced back, it’s gone and it’s gone,” Grenville said of the capsize, while Rosel recalled waking up on the floor when a big splash pitched water into the boat, managing only to wake the little boy so he sat up on their five-foot bench before another swell struck and sent the vessel under as she tried to wake the girl.
Absent crew, zero safety briefings and inaccessible life jackets
Pointing directly to crew visibility and basic passenger safety failures, Grenville testified that while crew members in shirts were seen when the family boarded around one o’clock and up until four o’clock, no crew members were seen after four o’clock and none ever briefed passengers on safety procedures or life jacket locations.
“Did they tell you anything about, well, where the life jackets are?” a commissioner asked, to which Grenville replied, “No,” confirming that no announcements were made at any stage of the trip.
That lack of guidance compounded the physical barriers aboard the crowded vessel, where the five family members shared a single five-foot bench in the middle section between two passageways near a funnel, blue side curtains had been dropped down during travel, and children were sleeping across the floor and passageways after nine o’clock, leaving no room to walk without stepping on someone. Grenville testified that life jackets were stored overhead on the opposite side inside a spaced-out mesh or grid box that tall adults could reach by stretching, though children could not, and the speed of the sinking left no time to reach them.
“It so quickly happened, we didn’t get a chance to hold a life jacket, to save none of the children,” Grenville said, noting that they could not even grab their bags, including the cash he was carrying back from Georgetown after failing to complete a vehicle purchase during their week-long stay on the highway for the funeral of Rosel’s nephew.
The testimony also provides insight into both the seven-hour ordeal at sea and the drop-off in state mental health follow-up for grieving families after they buried their children.
Trapped underwater in total darkness and swallowing salt water after the boat went under just before ten o’clock at night, Grenville forced his way out into the open ocean, where he surfaced, found a floating life jacket that jammed against him and fitted onto him along with a bottle that helped keep him afloat, and drifted alone until Coast Guard rescue at five o’clock in the morning.
“I confess I sinned. I was already dying in the water,” Grenville told the inquiry, while Rosel recounted going under three times before surfacing and clinging alongside several other survivors to what looked like a blue ice box cover until the Coast Guard pulled her aboard around five o’clock in an exhausted, lifeless state, reuniting her on the rescue boat with Grenville and their surviving son, Alex Smith, before they were taken to Pomeroon and Charity for dry clothes, shelter, and hot tea and flown back home via Mabaruma around midnight on Sunday.
While both parents confirmed they initially received counseling, with Grenville noting visits about twice a month and Rosel recalling psychologists visiting and later speaking with her by phone, Rosel revealed that all support had quietly ceased over the past month, which lead to her closing demand to the commissioners, “Then after that, I used to call on phone, but like for a month now, we don’t get no call, nothing no more, no visit no more.”













