“Mommy!” – mother recalls daughter’s cries as MV Barima went under

November 22 2026
-Mother recounts losing son and nephew in MV Barima sinking after crew brushed off lower-deck water
A Port Kaituma mother and grandmother who lost her 16-year-old son and her nephew when the MV Barima sank on July 18, 2026 has testified before the Commission of Inquiry (COI) that a crew member dismissed significant water downstairs as normal, while she held onto a mattress and a red flare shot into the night sky before Coast Guard rescue boats arrived.
Appearing before the inquiry, Anndyar Deally detailed her travel history, ticket and cargo arrangements, the capsizing, and her harrowing night in the water alongside her eight-year-old daughter, Joandrie Deally, and a 13-year-old girl she was accompanying back to Port Kaituma. Deally explained that she lived in Venezuela from around age nine after her Guyanese parents took her and her siblings there, accounting for Spanish inflections in her speech, before returning to Guyana so her children could know their family here.
Deally testified that the July 18 trip was her third time traveling on the MV Barima, having come down from Port Kaituma to Georgetown two weeks earlier, in the fourth week of June or early July, and once before that, but her first time traveling back up from Georgetown with cargo. She had come to Georgetown with her pregnant older, her 16-year-old son Andrew Batista, her eight-year-old daughter Joandrie, her nephew Luis Castillo, and Castillo’s girlfriend to obtain birth certificates for her children, having been told in Port Kaituma she had to come to town, while her pregnant daughter also had personal matters and took a plane back rather than risk the boat after becoming severely seasick and vomiting alongside little Joandrie on the trip down. Deally noted she is now the grandmother of a two-month-old baby, and confirmed that her nephew Luis Castillo and eight-year-old daughter Joandrie survived, whereas her son perished.
According to Deally, she bought five tickets on the Wednesday before the Saturday sailing at the Kingston Wharf office, without being asked for identification, giving only names and her phone number while the clerk entered information into a computer, for her son, her daughter, her nephew, his girlfriend, and herself, and also had a ticket sent by phone from a mother in Port Kaituma for a 13-year-old girl she was taking back. Deally said she did not receive the physical tickets on Wednesday, returned on Saturday morning around 10:00 a.m. to collect them, kept all five tickets in her hand without having them taken before boarding, and also paid $10,000 something for extra luggage beyond one suitcase per person, receiving a receipt, for her fast-food business items (selling chicken and chips) and baby supplies for her daughter.
Arriving at the wharf around 10:00 a.m. on Saturday, July 18, Deally described a massive crowd inside and outside the waiting area and loud talk that tickets were sold out. While waiting, she peeped through the window three times asking why the ferry, normally said to leave at 1:00 p.m., was delayed so long, watched the vessel go out and come back three times on the water, saw workers packing heavy loads, and noted that everyone had to pass through a single small door where someone checked tickets before walking across a larger boat over a wooden plank to the second deck.
Once aboard around 3:00 p.m., Deally found the back packed with goods and seat backs crowded, so she and her group settled in a tight space in the middle section near the stairs going up and down, surrounded by bags and feed along the sides. Deally and her son lay in a hammock, while eight-year-old Joandrie and the 13-year-old girl sat on a nearby bench that had opened up.
Deally told commissioners that while standing near the front stairs upon boarding, she, her son, and her nephew looked down and saw a large amount of water downstairs, with her son using his cousin’s phone to photograph it (a phone that went down in the sinking, though he later recovered the pictures). When they asked a man dressed in what she recognized as crew attire, a blue jersey and black pants, whom she knew by face from Port Kaituma’s waterfront, why there was so much water downstairs, he told them it was normal sea wash-in and wash-out. Deally noted that on her two earlier trips from Port Kaituma to Georgetown, the vessel was far less crowded with few passengers and no cargo or water on deck, even when rocking heavily.
Deally said she slept from roughly 3:00 p.m. to 6:00 p.m., woke to eat with everyone, woke again around 10:00 p.m., told her son to get out of the hammock so she could move across, woke Joandrie and the 13-year-old girl, took them to the washroom, noticed lights in the distance wondering if they were getting close, and sat chatting with Joandrie and another woman near her. Checking her phone at 10:18 p.m., she heard a sound, like a wave or swell, about five minutes later as the boat heeled to the side, sending people on the floor rolling.
“And when I ended up running, the same force of the people there make me fall and when I follow, straight out of the boat, I roll out and from there, straight into the water,” Deally testified, recalling water in her face, her little daughter crying “Mommy,” and swallowing water as she realized she could not swim and pushed upward past people in the dark.
At the surface, Deally grabbed onto a mattress held by two men who were panicking, calmed them so all three could hold on, and also grabbed a white rolled floor covering, while seeing a red flare shoot straight up from the water. Praying and shouting for her son, daughter, and nephew amid widespread cries, she heard the 13-year-old girl call her name three times and say Joandrie was with her on an “ice pitcher” (cooler/ice chest). One of the men jumped onto a passing large cooler, while Deally and the other man swam toward Joandrie. Deally waited for a break in the waves, had Joandrie swim over to hold onto her and lean on the mattress between them, and continued calling out for her son, nephew, and his girlfriend.
Around an estimated 2:00 or 3:00 a.m., Deally heard a plane circle and shine lights over them, later joined another group holding onto a cooler, and around 4:00-something saw lights in the distance before growing exhausted with cramping feet and aching hands, pushing her hand through strapping/tape on the mattress to stay on until Joandrie held her hand to let her rest and promised to push her hand back in when she felt tired. Near 5:00 a.m., as Joandrie shivered from the cold, Deally asked a man on the cooler with another little girl if he could place Joandrie on top, which he declined because the other girl was already big.
When Coast Guard boats neared around 5:00 a.m., Deally and the others shouted and waved lights between waves until spotted. During the rescue, Deally recalled a large man grabbed a life jacket and threw himself into the water without waiting, nearly flipping the cooler, before crews threw another jacket, hoisted survivors aboard, with Joandrie sliding against the side of the boat and bumping herself during hoisting, and later transferred Deally to another boat taking her to Charity. A fellow survivor on the rescue boat told Deally he had seen her son and the 13-year-old girl on a cooler before waves separated everyone.
Deally recounted going to Charity on July 20, inspecting two sets of deceased victims before finding her son and her nephew in the third group, noting with anguish that their bodies were still intact and unswollen compared to others, raising questions in her mind about where rescue efforts had been focused. Commissioners offered their condolences and thanked her for providing testimony they called vital to their inquiry.













